Some homes are christened with champagne. Others with a housewarming party, a crowded kitchen, and music playing late into the night. But when Johnny Cash and June Carter moved into their new home on Old Hickory Lake in Hendersonville, Tennessee, Johnny Cash had something much quieter in mind.

He wanted the very first song ever sung inside those walls to be a hymn. And he wanted it sung by four men he believed in long before the rest of the world did: The Statler Brothers.

A House Waiting for Its First Note

The house on Old Hickory Lake was unlike any ordinary Nashville-area home. Built from stone and wood and set right on the water, it would become one of the most famous residences in country music history. Johnny Cash and June Carter would live there for decades, raising a family, hosting legendary musicians, and filling the rooms with songs.

But before any of that happened, the house was silent. Johnny Cash wanted that silence broken in a way that meant something.

The Young Quartet Johnny Cash Took a Chance On

To understand why Johnny Cash chose The Statler Brothers, you have to go back to 1964. Don Reid, Harold Reid, Phil Balsley, and Lew DeWitt were a young vocal group from Staunton, Virginia. They had grown up singing gospel music, harmonizing in churches and small gatherings, dreaming of something bigger.

Johnny Cash heard something in them. He brought the group onto his road show in 1964, giving them a stage in front of audiences they could never have reached on their own. It was a generous move from an artist who was already a giant in country music.

The gamble paid off. In 1965, The Statler Brothers released “Flowers on the Wall,” written by Lew DeWitt. The song became a major hit and won a Grammy Award. Over the years that followed, the quartet would grow into one of the most beloved and awarded vocal groups in country music history.

But they never forgot who opened the door for them. And Johnny Cash never forgot where their voices came from: the church.

A Special Request

When Johnny Cash and June Carter invited the four men to see their new home, Johnny Cash made a request. He didn’t ask for one of his own hits. He didn’t ask for “Flowers on the Wall.” He asked for a hymn.

He asked them to sing “How Great Thou Art.”

It was a fitting choice. The hymn has a remarkable history of its own. It began as a Swedish poem written by Carl Boberg in 1885, inspired by the beauty and power of nature. Decades later, English missionary Stuart K. Hine translated and expanded it, and the hymn spread around the world. By the mid-twentieth century, it had become one of the most beloved hymns in America, sung in churches, at revivals, and by artists across every genre.

For gospel-raised singers like The Statler Brothers, it was a song they knew by heart. For Johnny Cash, whose faith ran deep through his life and music, it was the perfect blessing for a new beginning.

Six Voices in a Circle at Twilight

Don Reid later recalled the moment. As twilight fell over Old Hickory Lake, all six of them gathered together: Johnny Cash, June Carter, Don Reid, Harold Reid, Phil Balsley, and Lew DeWitt. They stood in a circle inside the empty house, and they sang.

No stage lights. No microphones. No audience. Just six voices filling a brand-new home for the very first time.

Think about who was standing in that circle. A man who had already sold millions of records. A woman from the legendary Carter Family, country music royalty by birth. And four young men who had once been unknowns, now standing shoulder to shoulder with the people who had believed in them.

A Performance Unlike Any Other

In the years that followed, The Statler Brothers sang in front of enormous crowds. They performed on television, filled concert halls, and collected award after award. Don Reid stood on more stages than he could probably count.

Yet when he looked back, that quiet evening on Old Hickory Lake stood apart. He remembered it as a performance unlike any they had given before or would ever give again.

Maybe that’s because it wasn’t really a performance at all. Nobody was being entertained. Nobody was clapping. It was friendship, faith, and gratitude, expressed in the only language these six people knew best: harmony.

Why This Story Still Matters

Country music history is full of big moments: chart-topping hits, sold-out arenas, award shows. But sometimes the moments that matter most happen in empty rooms, far away from any crowd.

Johnny Cash could have filled his new home with any sound in the world. He chose an old hymn, sung by friends he had helped lift up, as the sun went down over the lake. That says a lot about who Johnny Cash was.

And every time you hear “How Great Thou Art” now, you might picture those six voices in a circle, blessing a house that would go on to hold a lifetime of music.