If you guessed “September When It Comes,” you were right. The song was written by Rosanne Cash and John Leventhal and recorded as a duet by Rosanne Cash and her father, Johnny Cash. It appeared on Rosanne Cash’s 2003 album Rules of Travel, and it became the last duet the two would share. Here is the full story behind it.
An Album That Almost Never Happened
Rosanne Cash and her husband and producer, John Leventhal, began work on Rules of Travel around 1998. Then everything stopped. During her pregnancy, a polyp formed on Rosanne Cash’s vocal cords, and for a long stretch she could not sing at all. The half-finished album was set aside.
The songs waited on the shelf for years. Once Rosanne Cash was able to sing again, she went back to the record. Looking back, she said the album was “all about loss and recovery.” She did not yet know how true that would turn out to be.
Pages Left Lying Around the House
Among the new pieces was a set of lyrics Rosanne Cash had written while thinking about something every child dreads: the day she would lose her father. The words trace her own life, from birth and childhood to the deep bond she shared with Johnny Cash.
She did not treat the pages as anything special. She left them lying around for days, until John Leventhal found them and asked what they were. He set the words to music, and then he made a suggestion that changed everything.
“If there was ever a song to sing with your dad, this would be it.”
Rosanne Cash resisted the idea at first. Over time she came to see that John Leventhal was right.
“I’ll Have to See the Lyrics First”
So Rosanne Cash called her father and asked whether he would sing the song with her. Johnny Cash was a legend by then, with nearly fifty years of records behind him, but he did not say yes right away. He gave the answer of a working songwriter.
“I’ll have to see the lyrics first.”
Rosanne Cash laughed about it later and called him “ever the professional.” In another interview she put it simply: “Dad’s very tough, very professional.” Johnny Cash read the words, and he agreed to sing.
A Sick Man at the Microphone
By then Johnny Cash was seriously ill. Rosanne Cash later said he was very sick, yet he still went to the studio and recorded his part. In the song, he enters partway through, as if answering his daughter. Near the end they trade lines, with Rosanne Cash finishing her father’s sentence, and the two voices close in unison.
Even after all that effort, Johnny Cash did not consider the job finished. He told Rosanne Cash to take the recording to John Leventhal. If John Leventhal did not like it, Johnny Cash said, he would come back and do it again. He thought the take was good enough, and it was.
The Release, and the Goodbye
Rules of Travel came out on Capitol Records in the spring of 2003. It was Rosanne Cash’s first album of new material in nearly seven years. NPR noted that it was the first time since the early 1980s that father and daughter had sung together on a record. The album reached No. 16 on the Billboard Top Country Albums chart and earned a Grammy nomination for Best Contemporary Folk Album.
On September 12, 2003, only a few months after the album’s release, Johnny Cash died at the age of 71.
Why the Song Still Matters
Many songs are written about losing a parent, but very few are sung by that parent. “September When It Comes” is a daughter preparing to say goodbye, and a father standing beside her in the same song, calmly facing what was ahead.
The song also shows who Johnny Cash was at the very end. He was sick and tired, but he still asked to read the lyrics first, still showed up, and still offered to do it again. For Rosanne Cash, it became a final record of the voice that shaped her life. For listeners, it remains one of the most quietly moving goodbyes in country music.
