Scroll to the end of the article to hear the song.
The song is “Whiskey Lullaby,” the Brad Paisley and Alison Krauss duet that won CMA Song of the Year in 2005. Before it was a hit, it was a few words spoken to Jon Randall on a friend’s couch, during what Bill Anderson called some pretty rough times.
Everything Went at Once
Jon Randall married Lorrie Morgan in 1996. The two sang together on “By My Side,” a duet that reached the Top 40 on the country charts. In 1999, the marriage ended. In the same stretch, he lost his recording contract and his song publishing deal.
Bill Anderson, who co-wrote the song with Randall, has told this part several ways over the years. In one account to The Boot, he said the divorce and the loss of both deals came within a day or two of each other. A No Depression profile of Randall written at the time put all three losses inside a single month.
In a 2025 interview with Dillon Weldon, Anderson remembered it even more sharply. The two had a writing date set about two weeks out, and Anderson ran into Randall in the parking lot at Sony’s publishing office. When Anderson said he was looking forward to writing with him, Randall checked his watch. It was only two o’clock, he said, and he had already lost his wife, his publishing deal and his recording contract that day.
“I don’t know what else I’m going to lose before the day is over.”
He told Anderson he honestly didn’t know if he’d be in any shape to write a song in two weeks.
Two Weeks on a Friend’s Couch
According to Anderson, Randall went and crashed at a friend’s house for a couple of weeks. “Things were pretty bad,” Anderson said. When Randall finally came out of it and sobered up, he apologized to his friend for the way he’d acted and for being an intruder in the man’s home.
The friend told him it was all right. Then he added:
“I’ve put the bottle to my head and pulled the trigger a few times.”
That sentence stayed with Jon Randall. By the time he sat down with Anderson, it was still fresh on his mind.
Forget the Midnight Cigarette
Bill Anderson came to the session with his own idea, a song called “Midnight Cigarette.” He pictured a relationship that doesn’t end all at once but burns out slowly, the way a cigarette does. Randall liked the line. Then, by Anderson’s account, he offered an idea of his own, drawn from what his friend had said, and played something on the guitar he’d been working on for about a week.
Anderson said that once he heard the story, he forgot all about his own idea. He told Randall to forget the midnight cigarette, because he had the perfect idea for the song right there. The cigarette did not disappear completely. It became the opening line of “Whiskey Lullaby,” and the friend’s sentence became the line that ends both of the song’s doomed lovers.
Anderson has always given Randall much of the credit. He called it a true collaboration and said the song “just kind of flowed” once they found it.
Written for One Voice
Bill Anderson and Jon Randall wrote “Whiskey Lullaby” for a single singer. The Dixie Chicks had it on hold first. While it sat there, Brad Paisley heard it and placed a hold of his own, and he got the green light to record it in 2003.
Paisley then called Anderson with an idea Anderson had never thought of: what if a woman sang the second verse? The first half of the song follows the man, and the second follows the woman. Paisley told Anderson he wanted either Alison Krauss or Dolly Parton. Anderson was a fan of both, and Krauss took the part.
Released as a single on March 29, 2004, the duet climbed to No. 3 on Billboard’s Hot Country Songs chart. That November, it won CMA Musical Event of the Year and Music Video of the Year for the video directed by Rick Schroder. A year later, it won CMA Song of the Year, and it has since been certified double platinum.
The Man Who Got Up Off the Couch
The couple in “Whiskey Lullaby” never find their way out of the bottle. Jon Randall did. He went on to write and produce for some of the biggest names in country music.
In December 2021, at the opening celebration for Bill Anderson’s exhibit at the Country Music Hall of Fame and Museum, Randall sang “Whiskey Lullaby” with Carly Pearce for the man who had told him to forget the midnight cigarette.
