The answer is “Suspicious Minds,” the duet Waylon Jennings and Jessi Colter recorded together in 1970. When it first came out, the record barely made a dent. Six years later, the very same recording climbed to No. 2 on the country chart and helped carry the first country album ever certified platinum. This is how a song the world seemed to forget found its moment.

A Newlywed Duet

Waylon Jennings and Jessi Colter married in 1969. He was a hard-driving RCA artist who was already pushing against the polished Nashville sound. She was a gifted songwriter and singer from Arizona who had once been married to guitar legend Duane Eddy. Making music together seemed like the natural next step.

The song they chose was not new. “Suspicious Minds” was written by Mark James, and in 1969 Elvis Presley had taken it to the top of the pop charts. Waylon Jennings and Jessi Colter gave it a country reading, trading lines as a husband and wife singing about trust and doubt.

Jessi Colter left her mark on the other side of the record too. The B-side, “I Ain’t the One,” was her own song, credited to M. Eddy, the name from her first marriage. It is a small detail, but it shows she was already a songwriter in her own right and not just a duet partner.

The Song That Stalled

RCA released the duet as a single in 1970. It reached No. 25 on the Billboard country chart and then slipped away. For most artists that would have been the end of the story. The record went into the label’s catalog, and life moved on.

The next few years were busy ones. Waylon Jennings fought for the right to choose his own songs, musicians and producers, and his 1973 album Honky Tonk Heroes is widely seen as the first true outlaw country record. Jessi Colter signed with Capitol and in 1975 scored a smash with “I’m Not Lisa,” a song she wrote herself.

Jerry Bradley Goes Digging

By the mid-1970s, the “outlaw” sound was the most exciting thing happening in country music. Willie Nelson’s Red Headed Stranger was selling in huge numbers, and RCA executive Jerry Bradley wanted his label to share in that energy.

Jerry Bradley’s idea was simple and a little bold. He would gather recordings RCA already owned by Waylon Jennings, Willie Nelson, Jessi Colter and Tompall Glaser and package them as one album. He gave it a cover designed like a worn, bullet-marked wanted poster and hired Rolling Stone writer Chet Flippo to write the liner notes. Waylon Jennings agreed to take part, on the condition that his friend Tompall Glaser was included.

Waylon Jennings had mixed feelings about the man behind the project:

“I liked Jerry, but he drove me a little nuts.”

Among the tracks Jerry Bradley pulled from the vaults was the 1970 duet of Waylon Jennings and Jessi Colter.

Second Time Around

Wanted! The Outlaws was released on January 12, 1976. It reached No. 1 on the country albums chart, stayed there for six weeks and climbed to No. 10 on the pop albums chart.

RCA sent “Suspicious Minds” out again as a single, credited to Waylon & Jessi. It was the same recording that had stalled at No. 25 six years earlier, and this time it rose all the way to No. 2. Alongside “Good Hearted Woman” by Waylon Jennings and Willie Nelson, it powered the album past one million copies. In November 1976, Wanted! The Outlaws became the first country album to be certified platinum.

Why It Still Matters

Oddly, when RCA cut the album down for its first CD release in 1988, the duet was one of the tracks left off. The 1996 reissue brought it back, and it has stayed part of the story of outlaw country ever since.

Waylon Jennings and Jessi Colter remained married until Waylon Jennings died in 2002, and they recorded together again on later projects such as Leather and Lace in 1981. “Suspicious Minds” is still the duet that shows how patient luck can be. A married couple sang together in 1970, the world shrugged, and six years later the same recording finally found its audience.