Scroll to the end of the article to hear the song.

On the night of October 26, 2002, The Statler Brothers walked off a concert stage for the last time. Before they did, Harold Reid, Don Reid, Phil Balsley and Jimmy Fortune sang “Amazing Grace,” the same hymn that had been the first song the four of them ever sang together. Both the Associated Press and a reporter from Virginia’s The Hook reported it, and Jimmy Fortune later told the story himself on a Gaither program: the first song and the last song they shared were the same one.

That ending was not an accident of a tired night. The whole farewell had been planned almost a year in advance.

A Decision Made While They Could Still Choose

In January 2002, the group’s office in Staunton, Virginia, sent out a short statement. The Statler Brothers would retire from touring at the end of the year. The reasons were plain: they wanted to be free of a rigid travel schedule and spend more time at their homes in the Shenandoah Valley. Don Reid added that all four of them were looking forward to “kicking back and sleeping late.”

The group was not fading when it made that call. The Statlers were still selling tickets, still drawing loyal crowds, and for years they had kept a staff of six just to answer fan mail. Later that year, Don Reid explained the thinking to Billboard. They had talked about it for a couple of years and knew they could not last forever, so the question became simple:

“Why not [stop] when we want to—instead of when we had to.”

That is why the announcement came so early. Don Reid told Billboard that the group gave every one of its employees a year’s notice that January, so the people who had worked for them would have time to adjust, both emotionally and financially. Don was 57 at the time and had been on the road since he was 18.

Why Salem

The last show was booked at the Salem Civic Center, just down the road from their headquarters in Staunton. Don Reid said it was simply the biggest venue close to home they could play. The concert was billed as “A Final Bow,” and according to The Hook, tickets sold out roughly six months ahead of time, in less than 90 minutes.

The Associated Press counted nearly 7,000 people in the building that night, many of them longtime fans. One of them, 96-year-old Elsa Brinkley, put it about as plainly as anyone could: “They are just like the rest of us, they’re getting older.”

The Night Itself

Jimmy Dean came out to introduce the group. The Statler Brothers opened with “Do You Remember These?” and worked through the hits their fans had grown up with, including “Flowers on the Wall” and “Class of ’57.” All through the set, people kept walking up to the front of the stage with bouquets of flowers and small gifts.

Near the end, Don Reid read a list of thank-yous. He named the crew, the managers, the bus drivers, the wives, the mothers and the friends. He also named Lew DeWitt, the group’s original tenor, who had died in 1990.

That name carried extra weight on that stage. Around Thanksgiving of 1981, Lew DeWitt heard a young singer named Jimmy Fortune sit in with a band at a Virginia ski resort. When Lew needed time off for surgery, Jimmy later recalled, his was the first name Lew suggested. Jimmy played his first show with the Statlers in January 1982, and he became the group’s permanent tenor when Lew could not return to the road.

“Not Sick, Just Tired”

Before the final song, the Statlers made sure the crowd understood one thing: nobody was ill. They were not quitting because of bad news. They were simply tired.

Then they sang “Amazing Grace.” The Hook called it a moving rendition, and its reporter noted that the crowd let the group go without loud demands for another encore. After nearly four decades of Statler Brothers music, this foursome ended with the song they had started with.

After the Lights Came Up

The goodbye did not stop at the stage door. Five days later, on Halloween, the Statler museum in Staunton closed. The building, an old grade school the group had turned into its offices and museum, was headed back to being a school.

Jimmy Fortune, the youngest of the four, was the only one who kept going. He later said he began work on his solo career the very next day and opened for The Oak Ridge Boys eleven days after that. He went out on his own with the group’s blessing, and he even had a line ready for the occasion. The Statlers had spent their early years opening for Johnny Cash, and as Jimmy told them, “they started with Cash and ended with a Fortune.”