Scroll to the end of the article to hear the song.
In the summer of 1986, Ricky Skaggs was one of the biggest names in country music, a reigning CMA Entertainer of the Year with a string of No. 1 records behind him. Then a phone call from his first wife, Brenda, pulled him into the hardest days of his life. Their seven-year-old son, Andrew, had been shot in the face on a Virginia interstate. And before the week was out, it was Andrew, not his father, who decided what the family would do with the man who pulled the trigger.
A Sunday Night on Interstate 81
On Sunday, August 17, 1986, Brenda Skaggs was driving Andrew home to Lexington, Kentucky, after a visit with relatives. At about 9:20 that night, on Interstate 81 in Botetourt County, just north of Roanoke, she moved to pass a tractor-trailer. The driver fired a gun into her car.
The bullet hit Andrew, who was riding in the front passenger seat. It entered through his right upper lip, grazed his carotid artery and lodged in the side of his neck. He was rushed to Roanoke Memorial Hospital, where surgeons operated to remove the bullet.
Virginia State Police arrested the driver at a truck weigh station near the scene at about 1:30 the next morning. He was Edward Dean Duehring Jr., a trucker from Germantown, Maryland. Besides malicious wounding and shooting into an occupied vehicle, he was charged with possessing a stolen gun and with possession of cocaine, methamphetamine and marijuana.
“I Thought My World Had Just Come to an End”
When Brenda called, Ricky Skaggs assumed at first it was some kind of accident. Then he learned what had really happened.
“When I found out it was a road rage-kind of shooting, oh man, it just freaked me out. I thought my world had just come to an end.”
He caught a plane to Roanoke and, in his words, spent “hours and days there with him.” Wire reports at the time differed on where he had been when the call came, one placing him in Nashville and another at a show in West Virginia, but every account agrees he went straight to his son.
Andrew was awake and alert by the time his father reached him. A hospital spokesman told reporters the boy patted Ricky on the arm to let him know he was all right. Within days, get-well cards were pouring in from fans across the country, and a Tennessee truck driver gathered four pages of signatures from trucking companies and drivers to send to the family, saying most truckers were nothing like the man who had fired that shot.
What Andrew Said
Ricky Skaggs has never pretended he took it calmly. Speaking with Diane Rehm in 2013, he said plainly that he wanted to kill the man, and that he wanted him in jail forever. In another account, he said he had been “feeling bad things about the man.”
Andrew did not share that feeling. Ricky has told the story many times since, and his son’s words come out a little differently in each telling, but the heart of them never changes. In a 2013 interview with Fox News, he remembered it this way:
“Dad, we’ve got to forgive this guy because he doesn’t know Jesus. He doesn’t have love in his heart like I do.”
A 1990 newspaper account had Andrew saying they needed to pray for the man and forgive him, and placed the moment right after Ricky told his son the shooter had been caught.
Either way, it landed hard on his father. Ricky later said that when Andrew talked to him about forgiveness, he knew he was the one who needed to repent. Years later he put it this way:
“I knew if he could go through it and forgive, then what excuse did I have?”
And he never forgot whose job it was supposed to be. “I’m the father, I’m supposed to be the leader, showing him the way,” he said. Instead, the seven-year-old in the hospital bed had shown him.
The Courtroom in Fincastle
Duehring pleaded guilty in December 1986. At his sentencing in Botetourt County Circuit Court on February 19, 1987, he told the court he had been on a nearly impossible schedule set by his employer, driving from Maryland to California and Washington, D.C., in just over eight days on about four hours of sleep, and using drugs to stay awake. He said he had been drifting in and out of consciousness and hearing voices of people he believed were following him, and that he fired what he meant as a warning shot. He also said no one in the Skaggs car had done anything to provoke him.
Botetourt County Circuit Judge George E. Honts III told the court:
“I don’t see how any victim can be any more innocent than this 7-year-old boy.”
Duehring could have received 52 years. He was sentenced to 40.
The hearing also showed how far Andrew still had to go. Six months after the shooting, he had been through three operations and faced at least two more. Nine doctors had treated him, including a neurologist and a psychiatrist. His mother described a boy who was afraid of being alone, and afraid to ride in a car at night.
The Lesson That Went the Other Way
When Ricky Skaggs published his memoir, Kentucky Traveler, in 2013, he wrote about that August again, and admitted it was hard to relive, for him and for Andrew, who would read it too. “It was a tough time,” he told the Roanoke Times, “but he taught me a real lesson in forgiveness.”
By then Andrew Skaggs was a grown man with two children of his own. “I’m so proud of him,” his father said.
