Scroll to the end of the article to hear the song.

The song was “Time in a Bottle.” Jim Croce wrote it in December 1970, on the night his wife, Ingrid, told him she was pregnant with their first child. It sat almost unnoticed for nearly two years. Then, in the fall of 1973, it found a national audience just as it lost its author.

A Recipe Contest, a Baby, and a Last Chance

At the end of 1970, Jim and Ingrid Croce had very little to show for years of trying. The folk album they had made together for Capitol Records had gone nowhere, and they had left New York discouraged. Back in Pennsylvania, Ingrid was making pottery and Jim had taken a job driving a truck.

Ingrid later told interviewer Gary James how she broke the news: she told Jim she hadn’t won the Pillsbury baking contest she had entered, but they were going to have a baby. By her account, it changed something in him. She connected it to his upbringing in a strong Italian family, where the eldest son was expected to set the example. With a child on the way, he saw this as his last real chance to make it in music.

He sat down at the table that night and wrote “Time in a Bottle.” Ingrid has said that in the same burst he wrote “You Don’t Mess Around with Jim” and other songs for what became his first ABC album, put them on one cassette, and sent them out. (Her own website says it was the same week; the official Jim Croce biography and her interviews say that same night.)

Ingrid has never described it simply as a baby song. She told Gary James it was really about something bigger:

“more about the immortality of life.”

A Waltz Nobody Expected to Be a Hit

Producers Terry Cashman and Tommy West wanted the recording simple: Jim singing, his guitar partner Maury Muehleisen playing. The harpsichord was an accident. Tommy West told Mix magazine he spotted one at the Hit Factory the day before mixing, left behind by a jingle company, with movers about to haul it away. He recorded two harpsichord parts, then sent the movers on their way.

Nobody on the team saw it as a single. West said they assumed it would only ever be an album cut. “You Don’t Mess Around with Jim” and “Operator (That’s Not the Way It Feels)” were the singles from that 1972 album, and by July 1973 Jim Croce had moved on to a new No. 1, “Bad, Bad Leroy Brown.”

Eight Days in September

On September 12, 1973, ABC aired a Movie of the Week called She Lives!, starring Desi Arnaz Jr. and Season Hubley as a young couple facing her cancer diagnosis. The producers had gone through stacks of albums before choosing “Time in a Bottle.” After the broadcast, viewers called stations wanting to know who was singing and where they could buy it. Jim Croce knew the song had suddenly caught the public’s attention.

That same week he finished recording his next album, I Got a Name, and kept up a busy run of college concerts.

On the night of September 20, 1973, Jim Croce played Prather Coliseum at Northwestern State University in Natchitoches, Louisiana. Less than an hour after the show, the chartered Beechcraft carrying him to his next concert in Sherman, Texas, failed to clear a pecan tree at the end of the runway. All six people on board were killed, including Maury Muehleisen. Jim Croce was 30. His son, Adrian James, was eight days away from his second birthday.

The Letter That Came Home

About a week after the crash, Ingrid received a letter Jim had mailed from the road. He was worn out by the touring and missed his family. He wrote about stepping away from the music business and working on short stories and movie scripts, the kind of work that would keep him close to home. According to Ultimate Classic Rock, he signed off this way: “Remember, it’s the first 60 years that count and I’ve got 30 to go.”

No. 1 at the End of 1973

“I Got a Name” came out the day after the crash, just as planned, and went into the Top 10. But the demand that had started with She Lives! kept growing, and ABC Records released “Time in a Bottle” as a single in November 1973.

On December 29, 1973, it reached No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100 and stayed there for two weeks. Jim Croce was only the third artist to top the Hot 100 after death, following Otis Redding and Janis Joplin. Billboard notes he also became the first artist in Hot 100 history to reach No. 1 both during his lifetime and after it.

The album did the same. You Don’t Mess Around with Jim had been on the Billboard album chart since July 1972. On January 12, 1974, it reached No. 1 and held the spot for five weeks.

The Boy the Song Was Written For

Adrian James Croce grew up to be a musician too, performing as A.J. Croce. Decades later, when he began playing his father’s songs on his Croce Plays Croce tour, he said “Time in a Bottle” was the hardest one for him to sing because it had been written for him. It was the last song he added to the set.

Ingrid Croce wrote that after September 20, 1973, the song took on a new meaning. A waltz about wishing for more time had been written by a man who had only a little under three more years of it.