Scroll to the end of the article to hear the song.
On October 14, 1970, at the Ryman Auditorium in Nashville, Roy Clark announced the Country Music Association’s Song of the Year, and the room was startled by the name he read: Kris Kristofferson, for “Sunday Mornin’ Comin’ Down.” The song had just beaten Merle Haggard’s “Okie from Muskogee.” And the first person to react to the upset was Merle Haggard himself.
Sitting Right Behind Merle
Kris Kristofferson told the story more than once in later years. He had no idea he was going to win. The category was full of writers he looked up to, Merle and Marty Robbins among them.
When his name was called, he straightened up so quickly that he hit his head on the back of the pew. That was not a figure of speech. The Ryman began life as a church, and in those days the audience still sat on long wooden pews. Kris happened to be seated in the row directly behind Merle Haggard.
In a 2013 interview with Rock Cellar Magazine, Kris remembered Merle turning around in his seat to face him and saying:
“Well, get on up there!”
He laughed telling it. He had given a St. Louis paper the same account a couple of years earlier, again with Merle turning around in the pew in front of him.
A few later retellings of the night put Marty Robbins in that role instead, urging Kris to hurry because he had a long walk to the stage. In Kris Kristofferson’s own accounts, though, the man who turned around was Merle.
A Few Words at the Podium
The walk up was the easy part. The broadcast shows Kris Kristofferson at the microphone looking like a man who would rather be anywhere else. Rolling Stone later noted that he stood for several seconds with his back to the audience, and once he turned around, he hardly lifted his eyes from the podium.
The speech lasted only moments. He joked, “I think Marty and Merle must be layin’ out,” as if the only way he could have won was if his two biggest rivals had stayed home, even though Merle had just spoken to him from the pew in front. He thanked Johnny Cash. Then he added that he was glad he had not been up against “Today I Started Loving You Again,” one of Merle’s own songs, and hurried off.
Kris later said the papers reported that he had mumbled something nobody could make out. Some accounts of the night have suggested he had been drinking. He denied it, and said it was the shock of hearing his name that left him so rattled.
It Was Merle’s Night
The upset stood out because almost everything else that evening belonged to Merle Haggard. He came in with nine nominations and left with four trophies: Entertainer of the Year, Male Vocalist of the Year, and both Single and Album of the Year for “Okie from Muskogee.” He even had two songs in the Song of the Year race, “Okie” and “The Fightin’ Side of Me,” alongside Conway Twitty’s “Hello Darlin'” and Marty Robbins’ “My Woman, My Woman, My Wife.”
Kris Kristofferson’s song had taken a longer road. He wrote “Sunday Mornin’ Comin’ Down” in a run-down Nashville apartment while his marriage was falling apart. Johnny Cash sang it on his television show in early 1970, and Cash’s live recording sat at No. 1 on the country chart the very week of the awards.
On paper, the two men looked like they belonged on opposite sides. “Okie from Muskogee” had been embraced as an anthem of the so-called silent majority, while Kris was the long-haired newcomer writing about a lonely, hungover Sunday. Kris later said everybody expected the two of them to be at odds, partly because he was about the only man in the business with a beard back then.
That is what makes the moment in the pew worth remembering. Merle had just lost the songwriting award to the newcomer behind him, and he turned around and sent him to the stage.
Forty Years Later
The two became close friends. By 2011 they were touring together, swapping songs on the same stage, and Kris Kristofferson, who died in 2024 at 88, was telling interviewers that Merle Haggard was his hero.
Merle died on April 6, 2016, his 79th birthday. Shortly before, he had asked Kris to take his place on a tour with Willie Nelson. That May, Kris stepped into the spot Merle left, sharing the stage with Merle’s sons Ben and Noel and Merle’s old band, the Strangers, and singing Merle’s songs.
