Scroll to the end of the article to hear the song.

When John Prine released his duets album In Spite of Ourselves in 1999, a copy was made for Iris DeMent’s mother, Flora Mae, with one track missing. It was the title song, “In Spite of Ourselves,” the duet her daughter sang with John. It would become the song Iris is best known for. But getting Iris to sing it at all took three weeks of silence, a phone call, and a quiet corner of a recording studio.

A Song Written With Her Voice in Mind

The album was Prine’s first release after his battle with cancer, and it was built mostly on classic country duets written by others. “In Spite of Ourselves” was the only song on it he wrote himself. He came up with it after Billy Bob Thornton asked him for a song for the film Daddy and Them.

The song is a back-and-forth between a husband and wife who list each other’s strange habits in comic, sometimes raunchy detail, then admit they are crazy about each other anyway. In a 2016 interview with NPR, Prine said he had Iris in mind from the start. He thought she had enough sass to cut the husband down to size, and she got the saltiest lines.

Three Weeks Without an Answer

Prine faxed her the lyrics with a warning that she would have to say a few questionable things, and told her the choice was hers. Iris had grown up in a Pentecostal household, where music meant gospel and church. In a 2023 interview with NPR, she remembered the moment the page came through:

“I came out of the Pentecostal church and I was like, ‘I can’t do this.'”

She said her heart started racing. Prine, for his part, heard nothing for three weeks. When he finally called and asked what she thought, Iris told him, “Not while my mother’s alive!” He later said she ended up doing it anyway.

Why She Said Yes

Iris DeMent told The Irish Times in 2023 that she felt she had to support John, who had just come through cancer. Prine had been one of her earliest champions; he wrote the liner notes for her 1992 debut album, Infamous Angel. Saying yes was one thing. Singing it was another.

A Little Corner of the Studio

In the studio, with Marty Stuart producing and the band ready to go, Iris DeMent found she could not get the words out. She would open her mouth and no sound would come. So John Prine asked her to join him in a little corner of the room. The two of them stood there facing each other. She focused on John, and they got through the take.

The record sounds loose and playful, the kind of song that makes a room full of people laugh. Iris has said that when she listens back, she can hear how close she came to breaking down while singing it.

A Copy for Flora Mae

Iris’s mother was a devout woman who sang gospel at home and in church her whole life. She even sang lead on “Higher Ground,” the closing track of her daughter’s first album. When In Spite of Ourselves was finished, a copy of the album was made for her without the title song. The accounts don’t say whether Flora Mae DeMent ever heard the duet. She died in 2011, at 93.

Only With John

The song Iris DeMent was afraid to sing became a fan favorite. She told NPR that everybody loved it, and that she has sung it countless times since. John Prine died in April 2020 from complications of COVID-19. Looking back on that session, Iris put it plainly:

“I would not have sung that song with anyone but John.”