Some songs stay with a singer for a whole career. They get played thousands of times, in county fairgrounds, casino showrooms, and big theaters, until the crowd knows exactly when they’re coming. For Mel Tillis, that song came last. Every night, it was how the show ended.
Most people in those crowds never thought much about what it said. It was the sing-along, the closing number. It took a funeral and a night at the Ryman Auditorium for people to hear it differently.
A Song Written for Somebody Else
The song was “Detroit City.” Mel Tillis wrote it with his friend Danny Dill in the early 1960s, back when Mel Tillis was better known in Nashville as a songwriter than as a star. Billy Grammer recorded it first, under the title “I Wanna Go Home.” Then in 1963 Bobby Bare cut his own version, and that one became the classic.
Bobby Bare later said that without Mel Tillis and “Detroit City,” he probably would not have had a career. The song connected with real people. In those years, thousands of young men from the rural South moved north to work in factories, and this song told their story.
The Story Inside the Song
The narrator is one of those men. At night he dreams of the cotton fields he grew up around, of his mother and father, his sister and brother, and the girl who has been waiting for him a long time.
His letters home say everything is going great. They think he has made it. The truth is less impressive: he works the assembly line all day and spends his nights in bars, wishing the people back home could read between the lines. In the spoken part near the end, he decides to put his pride aside and catch a train south, back to the people he left behind.
For decades, that’s how people heard it. It was a song about a homesick working man who was too proud to admit he was struggling, and who finally decided to go back.
The Night the Song Changed
Mel Tillis died on November 19, 2017, in Ocala, Florida. He was 85.
Eight days later, family, friends, and fans gathered at Mount Hermon Baptist Church in Clarksville, Tennessee. Songwriter Bobby Tomberlin was singing gospel music during the service when the performance slid into the familiar chorus of “Detroit City.” The whole church sang along softly.
Nobody had changed a word. The song still talked about going home and about loved ones waiting at the end of a long trip. In that room, though, those lines meant something new.
The Ryman Stands Up
On January 31, 2018, Nashville held a public memorial for Mel Tillis at the Ryman Auditorium, where country music has said goodbye to many of its greats. Ralph Emery hosted. Ricky Skaggs, Ray Stevens, Lorrie Morgan, Jamey Johnson, Alison Krauss, and others performed songs Mel Tillis had written or made famous. His old band, the Statesiders, played behind them.
The last song was “Detroit City.”
Before it started, his daughter Pam Tillis told the audience something longtime fans already knew:
“Daddy always closed every show with this.”
Her brother Sonny Tillis delivered the spoken recitation, the part about leaving and heading back to the people who were waiting. Tanya Tucker and the day’s other performers joined in. Pam reminded everyone that her father always loved it when the crowd sang along, and the audience stood up and sang with them.
Same Words, Different Meaning
For more than fifty years, “Detroit City” told the story of a man trying to get back to the South. At Mel Tillis’s farewell, the people singing it heard a different story: a man finishing his last show and heading home for good. The train south, the family waiting, and the pride he finally lets go of all seemed to point that way.
The song he closed every concert with ended up closing his farewell too. Mel Tillis didn’t write it as a goodbye, and nobody planned for it to become one. That night at the Ryman, it was.
Is there a song you can’t hear the same way anymore after losing someone? Tell us about it in the comments.
