Scroll to the end of the article to hear the song.

The song was “I Forgot More Than You’ll Ever Know,” a slow waltz written by Cecil Null and recorded by the Davis Sisters in Nashville on May 23, 1953. Betty Jack Davis sang the lead. Her best friend, Skeeter Davis, sang the harmony. On October 17, 1953, the record reached No. 1 on Billboard’s country chart. Betty Jack had been dead for eleven weeks.

“We’re Almost Home”

On the evening of August 1, 1953, the Davis Sisters made their first appearance on WWVA’s Wheeling Jamboree in Wheeling, West Virginia. After midnight they started the long drive back toward Covington, Kentucky, where they lived.

Forty years later, Skeeter Davis told writer Bob Allen what she remembered of that drive:

“We were driving back, and I looked at the map and said, ‘We’re almost home. We’ve just got a few more miles to go.'”

She said she remembered nothing of the crash itself. Around 7 a.m. on August 2, near Cincinnati, the driver of an oncoming car, a soldier on leave according to Allen’s account, fell asleep at the wheel and slammed head-on into their car. He survived. Betty Jack Davis, 21 years old, was killed instantly. Skeeter suffered serious head injuries.

In her 1993 autobiography, Bus Fare to Kentucky, Skeeter wrote that early newspaper bulletins got it wrong and reported both “sisters” dead at a Cincinnati hospital. She was alive, but she woke up to a different life:

“But when I finally did wake up in the hospital, Betty Jack was gone. And the whole world was changed.”

Betty Jack was buried in Highland Cemetery on August 6, 1953.

Two Friends, One Last Name

They were never related. Skeeter was born Mary Frances Penick. She met Betty Jack Davis at Dixie Heights High School in northern Kentucky around 1947, and the two began singing together every chance they got. Betty Jack used to tell her, “Skeeter, I never heard anything like you!” When they started performing, Skeeter took Betty Jack’s last name, and they became the Davis Sisters.

In 1949 they tried to get on the Grand Ole Opry. They were not allowed to perform, but they made it backstage. Skeeter later recalled Betty Jack turning to her there and saying, “Someday we’re gonna be out there.”

Their voices fit together without much planning. “Our singing style was never something we practiced or sat down and figured out,” Skeeter told Allen. Betty Jack sang a strong lead, and Skeeter built the harmony around it.

The Song on the Back of the Record

After demos in Detroit and a small single on Fortune Records, the girls landed a contract with RCA Victor and producer Steve Sholes in the spring of 1953. When their first RCA single came out that June, RCA treated a lively number, “Rock-A-Bye Boogie,” as the A-side. Billboard’s review in late June listed “I Forgot More Than You’ll Ever Know” on the flip.

Listeners had other ideas. By mid-July, Billboard noted that Memphis was showing more love for the B-side. By early August, the record stood at No. 1 in Memphis, though it had not yet cracked the national Top 10. That was where things stood when the Davis Sisters drove to Wheeling.

The Climb Without Her

In the weeks after the crash, the sad waltz broke into Billboard’s national country Top 10 and kept climbing. It reached No. 1 in October and returned to the top again and again through the end of the year. Chart historian Joel Whitburn credits it with eight weeks at No. 1, and it also crossed over to No. 18 on the pop chart. It was the only national hit the Davis Sisters ever had.

On the record, the two voices move together almost the entire way. As American Songwriter has pointed out, the one short stretch sung by a single voice belongs to Betty Jack.

What Skeeter Did Next

Skeeter Davis’s recovery was long. About six months after the crash, at the urging of Betty Jack’s family, she agreed to revive the act with Betty Jack’s older sister, Georgia. They made more records for RCA, but there were no more hits. “Georgia was a fine singer, but it just wasn’t the same,” Skeeter said years later.

She went solo, joined the Grand Ole Opry in 1959, and found her own fame with songs like “The End of the World.” On her first solo album, released in 1959, she recorded “I Forgot More Than You’ll Ever Know” again. This time there was no Betty Jack beside her. Chet Atkins had Skeeter sing the harmony part over her own voice, and the album was titled I’ll Sing You a Song and Harmonize Too.