Scroll to the end of the article to hear the song.

On January 5, 2019, the opening night of The Voice UK’s eighth series, Sir Tom Jones ended up singing “I’ll Never Fall in Love Again,” the record he has named as his favorite of everything he ever released. The man at the piano beside him was Peter Donegan, son of the late Lonnie Donegan, the friend who wrote the song and gave it to Tom more than fifty years earlier.

It began with a country song. Peter, a 35-year-old singer from London, walked out for his blind audition and sang Rascal Flatts’ “Bless the Broken Road,” reportedly playing one of his father’s old guitars. Tom Jones was the only coach to turn his chair.

“Any Relation to Lonnie?”

When Peter gave his name, Tom asked the question almost casually: “Any relation to Lonnie?” The answer was yes. Tom told fellow coaches will.i.am, Jennifer Hudson and Olly Murs that he and Lonnie had been close and had toured together. He also admitted he hadn’t known Lonnie had a son that young.

For British audiences, the name needed no introduction. Lonnie Donegan was the King of Skiffle, the Glasgow-born singer whose 1956 recording of Lead Belly’s “Rock Island Line” set off a craze that put guitars in the hands of a generation of British teenagers. In America, “Rock Island Line” reached No. 8 on Billboard, and Lonnie became the first British male singer with two U.S. top 10 hits. He died of a heart attack on November 3, 2002, at 71.

The Song Lonnie Gave Tom

Lonnie Donegan wrote “I’ll Never Fall in Love Again” with Jimmy Currie and released it himself in 1962. It didn’t become a hit. A few years later, while the two men were touring together, Lonnie told Tom he had a song Tom ought to hear.

Tom recorded it in 1967. His version climbed to No. 2 in Britain, and when it was reissued in America in 1969 it reached No. 6 on the Hot 100 and No. 1 on the Adult Contemporary chart. Tom later recalled that Lonnie sang it in his own skiffle way, completely different from how Tom would, “like somebody busking.” Years later, when ShortList asked Tom to pick his favorite song from his own catalog, he chose this one.

No Rehearsal, No Run-Through

On The Voice stage, Tom asked Peter whether he wanted to do his dad’s song. Peter later said the request caught him completely off guard. The show’s band hadn’t learned the song well enough to play it on the spot, so the suggestion came back that Peter could accompany it himself on piano.

“So, no run through, nothing! Let’s just busk this on national TV!” — Peter Donegan, recalling the duet in an interview with The Strange Brew

Piano was Peter’s first instrument. He has said he taught himself before his father arranged lessons, and The Telegraph reported that he had toured as his father’s piano player. So Peter sat down, and Tom Jones sang the song Lonnie had given him, with Lonnie’s son playing it. Watching from the wings was Peter’s mother, Sharon, Lonnie’s widow since 2002, who was seen shedding a tear. Peter’s wife and son were backstage too.

The “Fix” Question

Not everyone believed it. Some viewers decided the whole moment was staged, and even The Telegraph’s reviewer, Michael Hogan, admitted the cynic in him suspected it had been rehearsed, though he called it magical either way.

Peter answered the doubters a few days later on ITV’s This Morning. He said the exchange was filmed as it happened and took about 20 minutes from start to finish, and he pointed anyone who doubted it to his mother’s reaction on camera. He was also direct about Tom:

“I’d never met Tom before that night.” — Peter Donegan on This Morning, January 2019

None of that settles what producers knew in advance, and the show never published a minute-by-minute account of the night. What is on the record is what happened next.

What Came Next

Peter joined Team Tom, and This Morning reported that the duet had sent his father’s old song back onto the charts. But when the Battles aired on March 2, 2019, Tom paired Peter with 23-year-old Deana Walmsley on Bob Dylan’s “Make You Feel My Love.” Tom picked Deana. With no steals left to save him, Peter was out of the competition. Deana went on to finish as the series runner-up.

The attention brought Peter an offer from Polydor. The catch was that the label wanted him to re-record his father’s hits. He turned it down, saying he wasn’t a tribute act and that his dad would have hated it. Lonnie, he said, had told him that to make it in this business you have to write your own songs. Peter kept going as an independent country artist.

Tom Jones once said Lonnie Donegan sang “I’ll Never Fall in Love Again” like a busker. More than fifty years after Lonnie gave him that song, his son sat at a piano with no rehearsal and busked it on national television.