Scroll to the end of the article to hear the song.
Before Carrie Underwood performed for Toby Keith at the 2022 BMI Country Awards, she thanked him for showing young people like her that they could achieve something great. Both came from Oklahoma. On this night in Nashville, she could tell him in person.
The ceremony took place on November 8 at BMI’s Music Row office. Keith was receiving its Icon Award, and Underwood’s tribute centered on “Should’ve Been a Cowboy,” his first No. 1 hit.
The Song She Sang Back to Him
With two musicians accompanying her, Underwood kept her performance close to the original recording. Keith listened from the audience, and the room joined in a singalong. The song that had introduced him to country radio in 1993 was now being performed in his honor by another Oklahoma star.
That song also belonged to the part of his career the evening was celebrating: his songwriting. In his acceptance speech, Keith explained that he had come to Nashville without knowing whether he would succeed as a recording artist. If his writing was good enough, he believed another singer might record it.
He recalled joining BMI around 1990 or 1991, after being advised to affiliate with a performing rights organization. His relationship with the company had lasted through the career that followed.
What Keith Wanted to Be Recognized For
Keith described the artists whose cassettes and CDs he had listened to: performers who also wrote songs. That combination had shaped what he wanted to do himself.
Underwood’s performance was part of a tribute that also included Eric Church singing “I Love This Bar” and longtime collaborators Dean Dillon and Scotty Emerick performing “A Little Too Late.” Each selection brought one of Keith’s songs into the room through another voice.
Keith closed his remarks by naming three honors he had cared about: the Songwriters Hall of Fame, the Nashville Songwriters Hall of Fame, and the BMI Icon Award he had just received.
