Scroll to the end of the article to hear the song.
On Friday night, October 13, 2023, Jason Aldean brought his Highway Desperado Tour to the Paycom Center in Oklahoma City. He was hoping for a special guest. Toby Keith, Oklahoma’s own, had a chance of joining him onstage. But Toby had already made another promise for that night, and it came first: he was going to watch his grandson play football.
“I Should Be Back Around 10:30”
Jason Aldean told the story a few days later on Taste of Country Nights. Toby had been upfront with him. He was going to the game, and he would try to get back in time for the concert.
“He’s like, ‘I should be back around 10:30,'” Aldean recalled. “I’m like, ‘the show ends at 11, man.'”
That left almost no room for error. Toby Keith was 62 years old and had been in treatment for stomach cancer since late 2021. For most of the show, it looked like the surprise might not happen at all.
Then, with just a few songs left before the end of the night, word reached Aldean that Toby had arrived.
The Introduction He Never Got to Finish
Aldean had a plan. He wanted to build the moment up properly for Toby’s hometown crowd.
“I was gonna give him this big announcement, set it up to blow the roof off the place,” Aldean said.
The crowd beat him to it. Aldean looked over at the pit and saw fans already going wild, because Toby was already walking out. In Aldean’s words, he came “just sashaying on stage like he does. Place went crazy.”
In video from that night, Aldean can be heard telling the arena there was only one guy you think of when you come to Oklahoma City, then calling out the “Big Dawg Daddy” by name.
“Should’ve Been a Cowboy” in Oklahoma City
They chose the song that started it all. “Should’ve Been a Cowboy,” written by Toby Keith alone, was his debut single in 1993 and his first No. 1. Aldean mostly let Toby take the lead, backing him on guitar and joining in on the chorus while the crowd sang every line.
The next day, Toby Keith’s official account posted that he had joined Aldean in Oklahoma City “and the crowd sang every word.” Aldean had already posted that night that some nights you never forget, and that he had one of those in Oklahoma City.
Toby didn’t leave right after the song, either. According to Aldean, he stayed for several hours, hanging out and swapping stories with Aldean and his band.
What Jason Aldean Saw That Night
Aldean had seen Toby about a year earlier and had followed his cancer battle, so he wasn’t shocked by how thin his friend looked. What stayed with him was something else.
“He’s a tough guy. All the things he’s gone through the last couple years, to still jump and play and still wanna do that, it says a lot about him.”
Speaking to Fox News Digital that same month, Aldean singled it out as a highlight. It was a hometown crowd for Toby, he said, and “one of those kind of electric nights.”
Two months later, Toby Keith played three comeback shows in Las Vegas. On December 14, 2023, he sang “Should’ve Been a Cowboy” on a stage for the final time. He died on February 5, 2024, at the age of 62.
The Same Song, Seven Months Later
When the Academy of Country Music asked Jason Aldean to honor Toby at the 59th ACM Awards in Frisco, Texas, on May 16, 2024, he went back to the song they had shared in Oklahoma City. This time it was quiet. Aldean sat on a stool with two acoustic guitar players and a string quartet, and slowed “Should’ve Been a Cowboy” down into something close to a ballad.
Before the show, he told the Tennessean that the song had always been a big part of his career.
“Even when I started playing in clubs early on at 14 and 15 years old I was up there playing ‘Should’ve Been a Cowboy,'” Jason Aldean said.
Toby’s family was in the audience, including his wife, Tricia, appearing at a public event for the first time since his death. Cameras caught tears on their faces as the song closed. As the final note faded, Aldean said simply, “We love you, Toby.”
Host Reba McEntire, another Oklahoman, seemed visibly moved. “Way to go, Jason. That was beautiful,” she told him.
Later that night, the Covel family released a statement thanking Aldean and calling the performance “the perfect tribute to Toby Keith.” The next morning, Jason Aldean released the live recording and thanked Toby’s family “for letting me be a part of this.”
