Scroll to the end of the article to hear the song.
The song is “Let the Mystery Be,” the cheerful little tune that opened Iris DeMent’s 1992 debut album, Infamous Angel. It shrugs at the biggest question there is, where we go when this life is over, and decides it is fine not to know. What makes it remarkable is who wrote it: a woman who spent her childhood on sidewalks with a tambourine, trying to make sure the other kids in town were saved.
The girl on the corner
Iris DeMent was born in Paragould, Arkansas, in 1961, the youngest of 14 children. When she was three, the family moved to California. Wherever they lived, life revolved around the Pentecostal church, where the whole family sang. Her mother liked to say she got each of her babies to church the first Sunday after they were born.
Members of her family often went door to door or sang in public to win souls. Iris went along. In a 2004 interview with No Depression, she put herself at about six years old:
“standing on the corner, shaking my tambourine”
Talking with Terry Gross on NPR’s Fresh Air in 2015, she described heading out with church groups before the Sunday night service, tambourine in hand, hoping to bring children to salvation.
A stack of New Testaments and a grown-up’s smile
Iris DeMent did not treat any of this as a game. She had been taught that people who were not saved would burn, and she believed it. If her school friends were in that kind of danger, she reasoned, nothing else could matter more. So she went to a church member and asked for New Testaments to hand out to the kids at school.
The grown-up smiled at her. Iris took it as the look you give a cute little kid, and it left her with a startling thought: this adult did not really believe what the church was teaching.
There was another thing she could not shake. On those sidewalks, she watched kids pedal past on their bicycles, kids who looked just like her. The belief she had been handed said she and they lived worlds apart, and something in her would not accept that.
Leaving at 16
By 16, Iris DeMent no longer believed that people were separated from God just because they had not claimed Jesus as their savior. She told Gross that she did not exactly choose to stop believing it. It simply stopped holding up, and that meant she had to leave the church.
It was not a happy escape. She described the day as a very sad one, because she was not walking away from people she disliked:
“I loved the music. I loved, you know, the community and the family.”
Her accounts of the break have different details depending on when she told them. In an earlier interview with Asheville’s Mountain Xpress, she pointed to a specific dispute: a minister told her she had to wear nylons or leave the choir. She knew of no Bible verse about nylons, and if he could think for himself, she figured, so could she. She left. In 2004 she told No Depression that she had already left the church in her heart and mind before she stopped showing up, after weighing each belief against her own experience.
Even then, she did not write off what the church gave her. She told Mountain Xpress it had been good for her in some ways, because at its best it speaks to the things that make life fuller and easier to bear.
No big story, just a whole childhood
Iris DeMent dropped out of high school, went back to school at 23, and did not write her first song until she was 25. That first one was “Our Town.” “Let the Mystery Be” came a few years later, and it led off Infamous Angel in 1992.
When Terry Gross asked her where the song came from, she said there was not really a story behind it, and admitted that was probably a letdown. But the conversation that followed went right back to the tambourine, the New Testaments, the kids on bikes and the sad day she left the church at 16. The song does not argue with anyone. It simply lays down the fear she had carried as a child and decides to live by love instead.
The song has traveled far. It opened the 1993 film Little Buddha, and in 2015 a version recorded for the Transatlantic Sessions became the opening theme for the second season of HBO’s The Leftovers.
Iris DeMent lives in Iowa now and still tours. She no longer belongs to a church, but she has said her music still comes from the spirit, and that she cannot do her work without that connection. She never stopped singing the old hymns, either. Her recording of “Leaning on the Everlasting Arms” plays at the end of the Coen brothers’ True Grit.
