Scroll to the end of the article to hear the song.

When Dave Cobb and engineer Gena Johnson set up a few simple microphones in John Prine’s living room one night in 2019, Cobb wasn’t thinking about a farewell. Cobb had produced The Tree of Forgiveness, Prine’s 2018 album and his first collection of new songs in more than 13 years, and in his mind this was the first step toward the next one. The song they recorded that night was “I Remember Everything.” It turned out to be the last song John Prine ever recorded.

“I just thought it was one of the songs we were going to put on his next album, not his last album,” Cobb later told MusicRow.

A New Song at Thanksgiving

Cobb first heard the song months earlier, at a Thanksgiving gathering at the Prine home. John was surrounded by family and friends when he pulled out his guitar and played something brand new, a song he had written with his longtime friend and co-writer Pat McLaughlin.

What stayed with Cobb was John’s excitement. In his words, John “was like a 15-year-old excited to play us his new song.” Cobb also admitted to American Songwriter that whenever you hear a new song from someone, you go in half prepared for it not to be as good as the last one. This one was.

A Phone Call From Fiona

A few months later, the call came from John’s wife, Fiona Whelan Prine. She wanted the song captured while it was still fresh.

Cobb and Johnson stopped by the house around 10:30 in the evening, just after Cobb had wrapped a different session. Cobb called that late-night window “perfect Prine hours.” There was no studio and no band. Johnson arrived early to set up, and John sat in his own living room with nothing but his acoustic guitar.

“It was very informal and it was really more documenting the song.” — Dave Cobb

John did a couple of run-throughs to warm up before they recorded, and from there, Johnson said, “It was basically one take.” Cobb remembered him “cutting up and cracking jokes, just typical John Prine,” and said John simply thought the whole thing was fun.

The Look Across the Room

Gena Johnson remembered one small moment from that night. As John sang the line about remembering the eyes of the woman he loved, he looked up at Fiona and smiled.

“His love for Fiona was the biggest thing,” Johnson told MusicRow. The camera that night caught the session in a single, simple shot: John at home, singing with his guitar, the way he had at Thanksgiving.

Plans for the Summer

To Dave Cobb, nothing about the session felt like an ending. Cobb said John was excited about the next album, and that the song was “just him playing a new song he wrote.” They already had plans.

“We had plans to go into the studio this summer, which is terribly sad.” — Dave Cobb

That summer never came. John Prine died on April 7, 2020, at 73, from complications of COVID-19. Johnson said it was heavy when he passed, and that she took it hard. Her first thoughts went to Fiona and the Prine sons, who had made her feel like family from the day she started working with John on The Tree of Forgiveness.

Shared at the End of the Tribute

On the night of June 11, 2020, the Prine family and Oh Boy Records streamed Picture Show: A Tribute Celebrating John Prine, a two-hour online celebration with friends like Bonnie Raitt, Kacey Musgraves, Jason Isbell, Brandi Carlile, Sturgill Simpson, Eric Church and Bill Murray. Dave Cobb was among the guests.

Viewers weren’t told what was coming at the end. As the evening closed, the family shared never-before-seen footage of John in his living room, singing “I Remember Everything” with his guitar, and released the song that night as a surprise.

What the Living Room Recording Became

The song that was meant to be the start of an album went somewhere John Prine had never quite gone as a performer. It debuted at No. 1 on Billboard’s Rock Digital Song Sales chart, his first No. 1 on a Billboard chart.

On March 14, 2021, “I Remember Everything” won two Grammy Awards, Best American Roots Song, shared with Pat McLaughlin, and Best American Roots Performance. That night Brandi Carlile sang it on the Grammy broadcast in his honor.

Fiona Prine, the woman he smiled at across the living room, put it simply after the Grammy wins:

“I often tell people if you want to know the story of John Prine, start reading the lyrics of the first song and go all the way to ‘I Remember Everything.'”