Scroll to the end of the article to hear the song.

The song was “I Wonder Do You Think of Me.” Keith Whitley recorded it in Nashville in April 1989. He died on May 9. RCA released it as a single in June, and on September 9, 1989, it reached No. 1 on Billboard’s Hot Country Singles chart. It was the fourth No. 1 of his career, and the first one he never got to see.

A Song That Sounded Like Lefty

The ballad was written by Sanger D. “Whitey” Shafer, a Texas songwriter who had written for Lefty Frizzell. That connection mattered to Keith Whitley. Early in 1989 he had gone to RCA chairman Joe Galante hoping to release his recording of “I Never Go Around Mirrors,” a Frizzell classic that Shafer had co-written with Lefty himself. Country Universe writer Kevin John Coyne notes that the new Shafer song appealed to Whitley because of how much it resembled “Mirrors.”

The story it tells is simple. A man thinks about the girl he loved in high school and wonders if she ever thinks of him: when she drives through their old hometown, past the school, past the park where it started. He remembers the football games where she treated him like a hero even though he barely got off the bench, and the graduation day when she drifted out of his life. By the end he admits he would go back if he could.

The Last Sessions

Whitley cut the album at the Sound Emporium in Nashville in April 1989, co-producing with Garth Fundis, the man behind his breakthrough album Don’t Close Your Eyes. That album had given him three No. 1 hits, and the third, “I’m No Stranger to the Rain,” had topped the chart that spring.

Accounts of how far the new album got differ. Many retellings, including American Songwriter and Saving Country Music, describe Whitley as having just finished the record when he died. Coyne paints a harder picture: he writes that the sessions were troubled, that Whitley frequently missed them, and that Fundis had to build the finished album from the work they had completed. Either way, the mixing and final shaping of the record happened after Keith Whitley was gone.

May 9, 1989

Keith Whitley died at his home in Goodlettsville, just north of Nashville. The medical examiner ruled the cause acute alcohol poisoning. He was 34. He had struggled with alcohol for years, and his wife, Lorrie Morgan, was out of town when it happened.

Lorrie Morgan’s Approval

The choice of first single went through his widow. According to Country Universe and Songfacts, Lorrie Morgan gave her personal approval for “I Wonder Do You Think of Me” to be the lead single. RCA released it in June 1989, about a month after his death. The album of the same name followed on August 1.

Listeners now heard a song about a man wondering whether he was still remembered, sung by a man who had just died. It reached No. 1 on the Radio & Records chart on August 18 and on Billboard on September 9, spending one week at the top and fourteen weeks on the chart. The album climbed to No. 2 on Billboard’s Top Country Albums chart and was later certified gold.

One More No. 1

RCA sent a second single from the album to radio in October 1989. “It Ain’t Nothin’,” written by Tony Haselden, was an upbeat song about love fixing what life breaks. It spent two weeks at No. 1 on Radio & Records at the end of December and reached No. 1 on Billboard on January 13, 1990.

That made five straight No. 1 singles for Keith Whitley: “Don’t Close Your Eyes,” “When You Say Nothing at All,” “I’m No Stranger to the Rain,” “I Wonder Do You Think of Me” and “It Ain’t Nothin’.” He lived to see the first three. A third single from the album, “I’m Over You,” peaked at No. 3 in 1990.

The Title Came Back

Whitley died three weeks before the Grand Ole Opry planned to invite him to become a member. On October 14, 2023, the Opry finally honored him with a special night of music. They called it I Wonder Do You Think of Me: The Opry Remembers Keith Whitley.

That night, Garth Brooks handed Lorrie Morgan a replica of the membership plaque Keith never received, and the Opry counted him among its members at last.