Scroll to the end of the article to hear the song.
By the early 1970s, Kris Kristofferson had everything a songwriter in Nashville could want. Johnny Cash had taken one of his songs to the top. Janis Joplin had turned another one into a legend. His name was on records all over the radio, and people in the business were calling him the best writer in town.
But a life on paper doesn’t always match the life a man is living. Larry Gatlin, who knew him then, later put it simply: on the morning this story begins, Kris Kristofferson was “not in good shape.”
An Invitation He Couldn’t Turn Down
The night before, Kris Kristofferson had joined a group of musicians in Cookeville, Tennessee, for a benefit show. When it was over, Connie Smith asked him whether he’d go to church with her the next day.
Church was not part of Kris Kristofferson’s life. By his own account, he hadn’t been since his first marriage, years earlier. He said yes anyway. He later explained that Connie Smith was so kind that he would have gone anywhere she asked.
She took him to Evangel Temple, the church led by Jimmie Rodgers Snow, a former country singer and the son of Hank Snow. Plenty of people in country music went there. To Kris Kristofferson, it was a room full of strangers and a service he planned to sit through quietly.
The Song That Started It
During the service, Larry Gatlin sang one of his own songs, a prayer called “Help Me.” Kris Kristofferson said later that it really moved him. Something in it reached a part of him he had kept closed off.
Then everyone knelt. Jimmie Snow asked whether anyone in the room was lost.
Kris Kristofferson later said that raising his hand was out of the question. He was not that kind of man. But his hand went up anyway, almost on its own. When the pastor invited people to come forward, he found himself walking down to the altar with everyone else, not really sure why he was there.
What happened next surprised him more than anyone. He began weeping, uncontrollably and in public. He described a tremendous relief, as if a heavy burden had been lifted from his shoulders, and a forgiveness he hadn’t known he needed.
A Song That Felt Like a Gift
Out of that morning came a new song. Kris Kristofferson always said it hardly felt like his own work:
“I really felt like I was just holding a pen.”
Larry Gatlin remembered it a little differently. In his telling, Kris Kristofferson wrote the song on the way home from church. That same night, he and Connie Smith came over to Larry Gatlin’s house to sing it, and soon afterward they performed it together on the Grand Ole Opry.
The song is short and humble. A man who knows exactly how he has lived looks up and asks why he has been given so much goodness. He wonders what he could ever do to earn that kindness, and how he could pay it back. He asks for help showing other people the road he has traveled, and he admits, without excuses, that he needs to be saved.
The Answer
The song was “Why Me”, also known as “Why Me, Lord.” Kris Kristofferson recorded it for his fourth album, Jesus Was a Capricorn, released in 1972 on Monument Records and produced by Fred Foster. Behind him on the record were two familiar voices: Rita Coolidge, who would soon become his wife, and Larry Gatlin, the man whose song had broken him open that morning.
Released as a single in 1973, “Why Me” reached No. 1 on the Billboard country chart that July. Kris Kristofferson wrote some of the most famous songs in country music history, but this was the only one that took him to No. 1 under his own name. It came from a moment he said he never planned and never fully understood.
The song went on to be recorded more than a hundred times. Elvis Presley sang it on stage, and Johnny Cash, Willie Nelson, Merle Haggard, Loretta Lynn and Connie Smith herself all made versions.
When You See a Rainbow
Kris Kristofferson died peacefully at his home on Maui, Hawaii, on September 28, 2024, surrounded by his family. He was 88. In their message to fans, his family asked that whenever people see a rainbow, they know he is smiling down at them all.
Decades earlier, he had walked into a church he never meant to visit and heard one man sing a prayer for help. He left with a song that said thank you, and it is still being sung today.
Which Kris Kristofferson song means the most to you? Tell us in the comments.
