Scroll to the end of the article to hear the song.

On February 13, 1988, Rosanne Cash’s “Tennessee Flat Top Box” reached No. 1 on Billboard’s Hot Country Singles chart. Billboard’s chart column that week noted that her father, Johnny Cash, had taken the very same song to No. 11 twenty-six years earlier. What the chart couldn’t show was the strangest part of the story: when Rosanne recorded it, she didn’t know her father had written it.

“I think it’s public domain”

The record almost didn’t get made. After her 1985 album Rhythm and Romance, Rosanne Cash was worn out by the whole process. In a 2017 interview with Texas Standard, she recalled telling Rodney Crowell, her husband and producer at the time, that she didn’t want to make any more records, even while her label’s lawyers were sending letters about an overdue album.

Crowell’s answer was to change the approach. He told her to make a real roots record and get away from the synthesizers and big snare sounds they had leaned on in the early ’80s. Then he suggested “Tennessee Flat Top Box,” and added that he thought her dad had written it. Rosanne remembered her reply this way:

“And I said no, I don’t think so. I think it’s public domain.”

It isn’t as odd as it sounds. Johnny’s single came out in late 1961, when Rosanne was six, and she had heard it all her life. She told Texas Standard the song simply felt like part of the air, something that had always been there. Years later she compared singing it to singing a lullaby she had known since childhood.

A first take to remember

The song went onto the album that became King’s Record Shop. At the end of the first take, drummer Eddie Bayers told the other players to pay attention, because they wouldn’t pass that way again.

“Because I wrote it”

There are two versions of how Rosanne learned the truth, and both come from the Cashes themselves.

In Rosanne’s telling, she asked her father after the recording was finished, and he answered plainly: yes, he wrote it.

Johnny Cash told it with more of a wink. By mid-1988 he was joking about it on stage, and Creem magazine printed his version that June. She played him the record, he said, and he told her it was real pretty and thanked her for recording it. When she asked why he was thanking her, he told her it was because he wrote it. Then he added:

“No, she didn’t know I wrote it. She sure didn’t, but that’s alright.”

The two accounts don’t match word for word, but they agree on what matters. She cut the song first and learned whose song it was afterward.

Twenty-six years after No. 11

Released in November 1987 as the third single from King’s Record Shop, “Tennessee Flat Top Box” became the third of four straight No. 1 country hits from the album. Not everyone found the backstory charming. Country Universe has written that the Nashville press made a fuss over the fact that Johnny Cash’s own daughter hadn’t known he wrote the song.

Johnny settled it in public. When the record reached No. 1, he took out an ad in Billboard and called his daughter’s success with the song

“one of my life’s greatest fulfillments.”

According to Country Universe, Johnny also made it clear he was glad she hadn’t known, because it meant she had recorded the song on its own merit and not just to please him. The Rolling Stone Encyclopedia of Rock & Roll would later describe her recording as a healing of her strained relationship with her dad. Coming from Johnny Cash, in the industry’s own trade magazine, it was a father’s answer to everyone who had made a fuss.

The song she kept

Rosanne Cash never let it go. By her own account in 2017, she had played “Tennessee Flat Top Box” at nearly every concert for thirty years. A few months after Johnny Cash died in September 2003, she sang it at a memorial for him. She told Texas Standard that the night was mostly filled with sadness, until she played that song.