Scroll to the end of the article to hear the song.

On December 17, 2023, The Oak Ridge Boys played a Christmas show at the Egyptian Theatre in DeKalb, Illinois. It was the last date of their holiday run, and it turned out to be the last time Joe Bonsall ever sang with the group he had joined in 1973.

Duane Allen, who stood beside him for fifty years, has told what happened next more than once. When the show ended, the Oaks helped Joe off the stage and into his wheelchair. Joe looked at his friends and told them he was finished.

“As we carried him off the stage and put him into his wheelchair, he said, ‘I’m done. I’ll call tomorrow,’ and he called Ben James.” – Duane Allen

The next morning, Joe Bonsall did something few men in his place would do. He picked up the phone and hired his own replacement.

A Fight He Kept to Himself

By then Joe was battling ALS, though almost nobody outside the band knew it. Duane Allen has said the Oaks knew about the illness for around four years. Joe spent two years under the care of doctors at the Mayo Clinic and Vanderbilt University Medical Center, and for a long stretch they could not even put a name to it.

When he finally spoke publicly, Joe called it a neuromuscular disorder and nothing more. Allen explained why.

“Joe just didn’t want any kind of pity party or anything like that happening.” – Duane Allen

On the road, fans could see the toll. Joe sang the whole show from a stool, and his bandmates helped him on and off the stage. What he would not risk was his voice.

“If You Go Down, We’re Going Down”

As Joe’s health slipped, the Oaks made him an offer that says everything about the friendship between these men.

“We told him, ‘Look, if you go down, we’re going down. We’ll just retire the group.'” – Duane Allen

The Oak Ridge Boys usually worked around 150 days a year. Allen asked Joe if he could handle about 50. That meant real financial cutbacks, but the group kept every one of its employees. Joe told Duane to commit to the dates. Early that year, he also made a promise about the holiday shows.

“Early in the year, he said, ‘I’m going to do my very best to make every Christmas show,’ and he never missed a show.” – Duane Allen

The Young Man Who Got Joe’s Microphone

Joe already knew who he wanted. Back in 2022, the Oaks shared a bill in Wheeling, West Virginia, with the bluegrass act Dailey & Vincent. In that band was a young tenor from Hickory, North Carolina, named Ben James, who had grown up with “Elvira” playing on repeat. That night he got to sing it with the Oak Ridge Boys, standing next to his hero.

Richard Sterban remembered that Joe handed Ben his own microphone on the second verse. Ben has never forgotten it.

“Joe handed me the mic and said, ‘You’ve got the next verse.’ And I’m not sure I will ever get over that moment.” – Ben James

“We all looked at each other, went, ‘Wow, this kid can sing,'” Sterban said. Ben knew every part Joe had ever sung. The Oaks brought him out on the 2023 Christmas tour, hoping Joe could ease out slowly while Ben eased in.

The Last Christmas Show

Joe Bonsall kept his promise. He made every Christmas date, and according to Duane Allen, the illness never reached the one thing Joe guarded most.

“He never missed a note. His voice was strong to the very last note of the last song we sang.” – Duane Allen

Then came the walk to the wheelchair at the edge of the stage. In another interview, Allen recalled Joe telling them, “I got to go home and deal with my illness.”

The call to Ben James came the next morning. Allen has repeated Joe’s words a few different ways over the years, but the heart of it never changes. In one telling, Joe said, “I’m done. The position is yours. Put your singing britches on.” In another, simply, “Ben, I’m done. Get on your singing britches.” William Lee Golden remembered Joe telling Ben he was passing the torch.

Singing for Joe

On December 30, 2023, Ben James played his first official show as an Oak Ridge Boy at Harlow’s Casino Resort in Greenville, Mississippi. Four days later, Joe announced his retirement from the road, admitting that walking had become impossible. He asked the fans for one thing.

“There is a young man named Ben James singing for me out there, and he needs your love and encouragement.” – Joe Bonsall

The Oaks still hoped Joe could sing on their next album, Mama’s Boys, so fans could hear the handoff from one tenor to the other. It never happened. Joe called Duane and told him his voice was husky and he no longer had the breath support to sing his part. “So you guys do the album,” he said.

Duane Allen visited Joe at his home in Hendersonville, Tennessee, on July 8, 2024. “I went home to get some rest, and he breathed his last breath about 3 a.m.,” Allen said. Joe Bonsall was 76.

The group that once offered to retire with him is still singing, with Ben James in the tenor spot Joe handed him. Ben James put it this way.

“And in my mind, Joe is still up there.” – Ben James